Made In Cookware Blue Carbon Steel Frying Pan
Made In Cookware Blue Carbon Steel Frying Pan

Made In Cookware Blue Carbon Steel Frying Pan

by Made In
We may earn a commission. Our picks remain independent. Disclosure

About the Product

The Made In Cookware Blue Carbon Steel Frying Pan is designed for cooks who value durability and long-term performance. Crafted from heat-treated blue carbon steel, it offers a factory finish that resists early rust and supports seasoning development, giving you a skillet that improves with use. While the pan is slightly thinner than some professional-grade models (~2 mm), it still provides good heat retention and responsiveness, making it suitable for searing and quick temperature adjustments on a variety of burners.

This pan comes with a lifetime warranty for defects, ensuring coverage for structural issues, although it does not cover rust, superficial damage, or misuse. Claims can be submitted online, but the detailed process and any potential costs are not fully transparent, so it's best to review the warranty carefully. The handle is riveted to the pan, offering standard strength and accessibility, and while replacement handles are not explicitly provided, the skillet is user-serviceable for cleaning, reseasoning, and minor repairs.

Overall, this skillet balances function, repairability, and heirloom potential. It can withstand high oven temperatures up to 1200°F, is compatible with multiple heat sources, and its carbon steel body allows repeated reseasoning cycles. Shoppers should note the pan may warp slightly under extreme heat due to its thinner steel, but careful use and maintenance will extend its lifespan well beyond typical nonstick alternatives.

About Made In

Made In is a U.S.-based cookware brand founded in 2017 with a clear focus on professional-grade performance and everyday durability. The company works with established manufacturing partners in the U.S. and Europe and emphasizes premium materials and construction techniques typically found in restaurant kitchens. Its messaging frequently centers on cookware designed to be used daily and to “last a lifetime,” which aligns well with shoppers looking for long-lasting products rather than trend-driven kitchenware.

From a reliability and consumer trust standpoint, Made In has built a solid reputation in a relatively short time. Independent reviewers from major food and home publications often praise its stainless steel and carbon steel lines for even heating, thoughtful design, and value compared to legacy brands. Customer reviews are generally positive, though not universally so—some owners report quality control or customer service issues, a reminder that the brand hasn’t yet earned the decades-deep track record of older cookware manufacturers.

As a company, Made In appears financially stable for its age, with private investment backing and ongoing expansion into new product categories and chef partnerships. That said, it remains a younger brand, and its public commitments focus more on performance than on explicit sustainability or repair programs. For shoppers prioritizing durability and modern direct-to-consumer value—and who are comfortable buying from a brand still building its long-term legacy—Made In offers a compelling, evidence-backed option.

Product Score:   50.8

Mission & Values
Whether the brand explicitly commits to durability, repairability, and sustainability.
Ideal: Brand mission and actions clearly prioritize long-lasting, repairable products.
Confidence — MEDIUM
2 sources
45.0% (W 40%)
PRO
Made In emphasizes high-quality, professional-grade cookware intended to “last a lifetime” and be used daily, indicating a focus on durability in design and materials. (brand site)The brand highlights craftsmanship and use of premium materials from USA & Europe, which supports long-lasting product performance. (brand site)
CON
The official mission and values language on the brand’s site focuses on performance and professional quality but does not explicitly commit to sustainability or repairability. (brand site)No explicit public commitments found regarding environmental sustainability initiatives or repair programs beyond product quality claims. (brand site; independent searches)
Track Record / Reputation
Independent history of reliability and consumer trust.
Ideal: Decades of consistent positive reputation from reviews, watchdogs, and experts.
Confidence — MEDIUM
5 sources
55.0% (W 40%)
PRO
Numerous positive customer reviews and high ratings reported on Trustpilot and the brand’s own site suggest strong consumer satisfaction and perceived product quality. (trustpilot; brand site)Independent reviews from multiple reputable food and cookware reviewers praise performance, durability, and professional-level quality rivaling established brands like All-Clad. (Food Network review; Business Insider; other reviews)
CON
The brand was founded relatively recently (2017), so it lacks decades-long historical reputation compared to legacy cookware brands. (Wikipedia)Some independent discussion forums and reviews note negative user experiences and quality concerns, indicating mixed consumer sentiment in parts of the community. (Reddit comment thread)
Corporate Stability
Financial and organizational stability of the brand or company.
Ideal: Established, stable company with low risk of discontinuing support.
Confidence — MEDIUM
2 sources
60.0% (W 20%)
PRO
Made In is a privately owned company founded in 2017 that has raised capital from notable investors including private equity and industry founders, indicating some level of financial backing and growth. (Wikipedia)The company has expanded its product range, presence in restaurants, and partnerships with chefs, suggesting ongoing business development and engagement in the cookware market. (Wikipedia)
CON
The brand is relatively young (founded 2017), which means long-term stability compared to century-old companies is less established. (Wikipedia)Made In is not accredited by the Better Business Bureau, and unresolved complaints are visible, which may reflect some organizational or customer service instability. (BBB profile)
Coverage
Scope of what failures the warranty covers.
Ideal: Full coverage of defects and workmanship, including all major components.
Confidence — HIGH
2 sources
60.0% (W 20%)
PRO
Lifetime warranty covers defects that impact use or longevity for Blue Carbon Steel products.
CON
Appearance changes, superficial damage, and rust are excluded from coverage.Damage from improper use, excessive heat, thermal shock, and accidental damage is not covered.
Duration
Length of warranty term.
Ideal: ≥10 years (lifetime where feasible).
Confidence — HIGH
1 sources
100.0% (W 30%)
DATA
Lifetime for defects
Ease
How simple it is to file and process a warranty claim.
Ideal: Clear online or phone process requiring minimal effort or paperwork.
Confidence — MEDIUM
1 sources
40.0% (W 10%)
PRO
Warranty claims can be submitted online via manufacturer site.
CON
No detailed publicly available step-by-step claim process or paperwork clarity.
Cost
Direct costs to the customer for warranty service.
Ideal: No cost to the customer, including free shipping and parts.
Confidence — LOW
0 sources
0.0% (W 10%)
DATA
Exclusions
Limitations or carve-outs in warranty terms.
Ideal: Few or no exclusions; coverage applies to all core components.
Confidence — HIGH
1 sources
60.0% (W 10%)
PRO
CON
Rust and superficial damage explicitly excluded.Damage from misuse, excessive heat, and thermal shock excluded.
Transparency
Clarity and accessibility of warranty wording.
Ideal: Plain-language warranty document published openly online.
Confidence — HIGH
1 sources
80.0% (W 10%)
PRO
Warranty terms are published on the manufacturer’s website in plain language.
CON
Transferability
Whether warranty transfers to subsequent owners.
Ideal: Warranty fully transferable between owners with no loss of coverage.
Confidence — LOW
0 sources
0.0% (W 10%)
DATA
Steel Thickness
Thickness of the carbon steel body, which strongly affects resistance to warping and long-term structural integrity.
Ideal: ≥ 3.0 mm thick for full-size skillets to minimize warping under high heat.
Confidence — MEDIUM
2 sources
20.0% (W 35%)
DATA
Approximately 2 mm
One-Piece Construction
Whether the pan body and handle are formed from a single piece of steel or permanently bonded.
Ideal: Single-piece forged or stamped steel with no welds at stress points.
Confidence — MEDIUM
2 sources
20.0% (W 25%)
PRO
CON
Handle is separate from pan body and likely attached with rivets or fasteners.
Heat Warp Resistance
Ability of the skillet to maintain a flat cooking surface when exposed to high or uneven heat.
Ideal: Documented compatibility with high-output burners and minimal reports of spinning or doming.
Confidence — MEDIUM
2 sources
30.0% (W 25%)
PRO
CON
Thin (~2 mm) carbon steel may be prone to warping under high heat or on induction.Consumer reports describe wobble or perceived warping.
Surface Treatment
Initial surface finish or factory seasoning that can affect corrosion resistance during early use.
Ideal: Bare or lightly pre-seasoned carbon steel with no fragile coatings.
Confidence — HIGH
1 sources
80.0% (W 15%)
PRO
Blue carbon steel has a heat-treated finish that helps prevent oxidation and aids seasoning.
CON
Handle Attachment Method
Method used to secure the handle, influencing long-term serviceability and strength.
Ideal: Riveted or one-piece handles with standard, accessible fasteners.
Confidence — MEDIUM
1 sources
60.0% (W 30%)
PRO
Handle likely attached with rivets which are a standard, accessible method.
CON
Replacement Handle Availability
Whether replacement handles or compatible parts can be sourced if damaged.
Ideal: Manufacturer-supported or standardized handles available without custom fabrication.
Confidence — LOW
0 sources
0.0% (W 25%)
PRO
CON
No clear evidence that manufacturer provides replacement handles.
Reseasoning Tolerance
Ability of the skillet to be stripped and re-seasoned repeatedly without damage.
Ideal: Safe for abrasive cleaning, oven seasoning, and repeated oil polymerization cycles.
Confidence — HIGH
1 sources
80.0% (W 25%)
PRO
Carbon steel material can be seasoned, stripped, and re-seasoned for long life.
CON
Repair Complexity
Overall difficulty of restoring performance after rust, carbon buildup, or minor deformation.
Ideal: User-serviceable with common tools and household methods.
Confidence — MEDIUM
1 sources
50.0% (W 20%)
PRO
Rust and buildup can typically be treated by seasoning and cleaning at home.
CON
Minor deformations from warping may be difficult to correct perfectly at home.
Heat Retention
Capacity of the skillet to store and maintain heat during cooking.
Ideal: High thermal mass suitable for searing and stable temperature cooking.
Confidence — HIGH
1 sources
80.0% (W 30%)
PRO
Carbon steel construction retains heat and provides chef-level searing performance.
CON
Heat Responsiveness
How quickly the skillet responds to changes in burner output.
Ideal: Balanced responsiveness that allows control without excessive temperature lag.
Confidence — HIGH
1 sources
80.0% (W 20%)
PRO
Carbon steel heats quickly relative to cast iron, offering good responsiveness.
CON
Oven-Safe Temperature
Maximum oven temperature the skillet and handle can safely withstand.
Ideal: ≥ 600 °F (315 °C) with no handle degradation.
Confidence — HIGH
1 sources
100.0% (W 25%)
DATA
Up to 1200°F
Handle Ergonomics
Shape and angle of the handle as it relates to control and fatigue during use.
Ideal: Comfortable grip with balanced weight distribution when fully loaded.
Confidence — MEDIUM
2 sources
60.0% (W 25%)
PRO
Handle shape generally described as comfortable and balanced in reviews.
CON
Some consumer commentary notes dissatisfaction with handle design or comfort.

See details on our Scoring Method.

Sources

These references are living documents: our research team and community continually review and update them to keep product evaluations accurate and fair. When stronger or more up-to-date sources emerge, we re-score accordingly. If you know of a credible study, review, or technical resource we’ve missed, please share it below — every contribution helps strengthen the evidence base.

  1. Made In Cookware Review
    foodal.com · Updated 2025-12-18
    Want to purchase premium cookware? Made In sells high-quality pots and pans. With a range of styles and materials, get exactly what you need. Read more now.
  2. 1nnvpnl
    reddit.com · Updated 2025-12-18
  3. Untitled
    reddit.com · Updated 2025-12-18
  4. Blue Carbon Steel Frying Pan Unseasoned Set
    madeincookware.com · Updated 2025-12-18
  5. Made In Carbon Steel Cookware Review (With Pictures) - Prudent Reviews
    prudentreviews.com · Updated 2025-12-18
    In this in-depth review of Made In carbon steel cookware, you’ll learn how it looks and feels, how it performs in the kitchen, what I like and dislike, what others are saying about it, and much more.
  6. We Found the Smoothest, Most Nonstick Cookware by Testing Carbon Steel Pans
    thespruceeats.com · Updated 2025-12-18
    Carbon steel is often used for woks and paella pans but is now a popular replacement for cast iron. We discovered and tested some of the best carbon steel pans available.
  7. Stay Away from Made In Cookware : r/cookware
    reddit.com · Updated 2025-12-18
    May 22, 2023 ... Stay Away from Made In Cookware. Review. I purchased a simple 12" fry ... Made In Cookware is selling an inferior product at elevated prices.
  8. Top 10 Best Carbon Steel Pans 2023 - YouTube
    youtube.com · Updated 2025-12-18
    May 19, 2023 ... ... Made In Cookware Blue Carbon Steel Frying Pan - https ... reviews, we were able to obtain a clearer vision of the best ...
  9. Gotham Steel Hammered Collection TV Spot, 'Reviews: Free Pan ...
    ispot.tv · Updated 2025-12-18
    Apr 28, 2022 ... Gotham Steel Hammered Collection TV Spot, 'Reviews: Free Pan' Featuring Daniel Green ... Made In Cookware Blue Carbon Steel Frying Pan · Gotham ...
  10. Learn a New Hobby Online: 10 Best Fun Hobbies & Projects to Try ...
    rollingstone.com · Updated 2025-12-18
    Dec 26, 2021 ... artifact uprising review. Buy Artifact Uprising Photo Book 20. 6. Made In Cookware Blue Carbon Steel Frying Pan. If you've taken up cooking ...
  11. Top 7 Best Carbon Steel Pans for Searing, Frying & Everyday Use ...
    youtube.com · Updated 2025-12-18
    Aug 24, 2024 ... ... Made In Cookware Blue Carbon Steel Frying Pan - https://amzn.to/4eepG5J # ... The Truth About Cooking With Made In Pans (No BS Review).
  12. Help! There Are No Good Non-Stick Pan Options - LeafScore
    leafscore.com · Updated 2025-12-18
    Mar 3, 2025 ... Alva Cookware Maestro Non-Stick Frying Pan · Alva Cookware Forest Frying pan [Staff Tested] · Made In Cookware Blue Carbon Steel Frying Pan.
  13. Help! There Are No Good Non-Stick Pan Options - LeafScore
    leafscore.com · Updated 2025-12-18
    Mar 3, 2025 ... read our review. made in carbon steel cookware. Made In Cookware Blue Carbon Steel Frying Pan. Leaf Score. Highlights: Well-made, ergonomic ...
  14. The 18 best kitchen items from Made In Cookware of 2022
    nypost.com · Updated 2025-12-18
    Oct 1, 2025 ... Made In Cookware's Blue Carbon Steel Frying Pan, impressively, is also available in a pre-seasoned form to skip hours of seasoning and get right ...
  15. What is the Best Cookware for High Heat? - FWDfuel Sports Nutrition
    fwdfuel.com · Updated 2025-12-18
    Apr 17, 2023 ... Similar to the Made in Cookware Blue Carbon Steel Frying pan, this pan is versatile due to being able to withstand high temperatures as well as ...
  16. Is made in worth it? : r/cookware
    reddit.com · Updated 2025-12-17
    Sep 23, 2024 ... I'm looking to get good/decent cookware for the first time and the made in looks good from all I can tell but I've seen some mixed reviews mostly warping and ...
  17. 16 CFR 239.2 - Disclosures in warranty or guarantee advertising ...
    law.cornell.edu · Updated 2025-12-17
    PART 239—GUIDES FOR THE ADVERTISING OF WARRANTIES AND GUARANTEES; § 239.2 ... made in the audio portion, or, if in the video portion, it remains on the ...
  18. The Made In Blog: Care - Made In
    madeincookware.com · Updated 2025-12-17
    The Made In Blog. Cook smarter with chef-approved techniques, product guides, recipes, and more to make the most of your cookware.
  19. The Ultimate Guide to Caring for Carbon Steel Cookware - Made In
    madeincookware.com · Updated 2025-12-17
    Mar 20, 2025 ... A person is holding a black and stainless steel stovetop grill with the label "Made · Care · How to Care for and Maintain the Made In Grill. By ...
  20. 16 CFR Part 239 — Guides for the Advertising of Warranties ... - eCFR
    ecfr.gov · Updated 2025-12-17
    ... warranty claim and the disclosure is made in the audio portion, or, if in the video portion, it remains on the screen for at least five seconds. See ...
  21. Warranty Policy - Made In
    madeincookware.com · Updated 2025-12-17
    Made In's plateware is protected by a 10-year no chip guarantee. Exposure to ... Made In's warranty does not cover accidental breakage. Bakeware.
  22. Made In Reviews — Over 100,000 5-Star Reviews - Made In
    madeincookware.com · Updated 2025-12-17
    Over 97% of verified customers give Made In Cookware 5-stars. Read all of our real Made In cookware reviews about our Stock Pots, Fry Pans, Nonstick Fry ...
  23. Warranty Registration - Made In
    madeincookware.com · Updated 2025-12-17
    You can register for Made In's limited lifetime warranty below with your email. Register Here You'll receive a warranty confirmation email following your ...
  24. How to use and take care of a stainless steel pan? : r/Cooking
    reddit.com · Updated 2025-12-17
    Mar 7, 2024 ... How to use and take care of a stainless steel pan? ... Looking for a good stainless steel frying pan, is Made In Stainless Clad a good choice?

Status

Created 2025-12-18 COMPLETE
Updated 2025-12-18 COMPLETE
Published PRIVATE
Scored 2025-12-18 COMPLETE

Change Log

2025-12-18 UPDATED product metadata edits
2025-12-18 UPDATED product metadata edits

Improve this Product

Know a trustworthy source we’re missing? See anything off in the scoring or data?