Matfer Bourgeat Black Carbon Steel Frying Pan
Matfer Bourgeat Black Carbon Steel Frying Pan

Matfer Bourgeat Black Carbon Steel Frying Pan

We may earn a commission. Our picks remain independent. Disclosure

About the Product

The Matfer Bourgeat Black Carbon Steel Frying Pan is a versatile and durable skillet designed for long-lasting performance in both professional and home kitchens. Crafted from a single pressed piece of carbon steel, the pan combines solid construction with riveted handle attachment for secure handling. While the steel body is slightly thinner than some heavy-duty models at approximately 2.0 mm, it still offers good heat retention and responsiveness for searing, sautéing, and frying. The pan comes with a protective vegetable oil coating, and requires initial seasoning to develop a naturally non-stick surface, which can be maintained and restored over repeated seasoning cycles.

Durability and usability are central to this skillet. It is compatible with gas, electric, induction, and glass cooktops, although gradual heating is recommended to prevent warping. The pan is oven-safe up to 600°F (315°C), making it suitable for finishing dishes under high heat. Users can manage minor rust or carbon buildup with standard kitchen tools and reseason the pan as needed, highlighting its repairable design. Handle ergonomics offer a secure grip, though the pan may feel slightly front-heavy when fully loaded, typical of carbon steel skillets.

Warranty and support reflect the brand’s commitment to longevity. The pan comes with a lifetime warranty covering defects in material and workmanship, with no cost to the customer for covered issues. While warranty claims can be initiated via phone or email, there is no online form or tracking system, and the warranty excludes damage from misuse or normal wear. Overall, this skillet offers a reliable, long-lasting cooking solution with a focus on durability, repairability, and consistent performance.

About Matfer Bourgeat

Matfer Bourgeat is a French cookware company with a rich history dating back to 1814, renowned for producing durable, professional-grade kitchen tools. The brand emphasizes long-lasting products designed to meet the rigorous demands of professional kitchens, with limited lifetime warranties on key items that reflect a commitment to durability and reliability. Their operations incorporate environmental and sustainability practices, including ISO 14001 certifications and eco-design initiatives, signaling attention to responsible production even if broader repairability programs are not widely publicized.

Over the decades, Matfer Bourgeat has earned recognition for quality and performance, including accolades from industry publications and positive evaluations from independent cookware reviewers. Their pans and kitchen tools are often highlighted for even heating, robust construction, and long-term usability, supporting a reputation for consumer trust and consistent reliability. That said, some users report variability in certain products, such as handle or weld durability, reflecting the nuanced reality of long-term use.

As a family-owned business with international operations and a U.S. subsidiary active for over 30 years, Matfer Bourgeat demonstrates organizational stability and an ongoing presence in professional kitchens worldwide. While detailed financial performance data is not publicly available, the brand’s longevity and sustained market presence suggest a low risk of discontinued support. For shoppers seeking long-lasting products backed by a heritage brand, Matfer Bourgeat offers a solid balance of durability, expertise, and professional credibility.

Product Score:   64.8

Mission & Values
Whether the brand explicitly commits to durability, repairability, and sustainability.
Ideal: Brand mission and actions clearly prioritize long-lasting, repairable products.
Confidence — MEDIUM
3 sources
50.0% (W 40%)
PRO
Matfer Bourgeat’s corporate statements emphasize durability and longevity, noting products are designed for professional kitchens to “last a lifetime,” with limited lifetime warranties on key lines, indicating an organizational focus on long-lasting products.The brand and its French parent commit to environmental objectives and sustainable growth, including ISO 14001 certifications, eco-design criteria, reduced waste and certifications like FSC/PEFC, suggesting some ESG-related operational mission elements.
CON
While sustainability and durability are referenced, there is no clearly articulated public mission statement on the US site that explicitly prioritizes broader sustainability, repairability, or product end‑of‑life support beyond warranty coverage.Evidence of formal commitments to repairability (e.g., spare parts programs, repair services) is not readily found on brand sites or independent sources. null
Track Record / Reputation
Independent history of reliability and consumer trust.
Ideal: Decades of consistent positive reputation from reviews, watchdogs, and experts.
Confidence — MEDIUM
4 sources
60.0% (W 40%)
PRO
Matfer Bourgeat has a long history dating back to 1814 and is a heritage cookware maker with documented industry recognition (e.g., previously named Best Pan brand in Restaurant magazine’s awards), indicating longstanding professional credibility.Independent cookware reviews often praise Matfer Bourgeat pans for even heating, durable construction, and strong performance in tests, supporting a reputation for quality among users and reviewers.
CON
Some user reviews note inconsistent quality experiences (e.g., weld failure, structural issues) and mixed community feedback on durability of seasoning or handles in consumer forums, which weakens uniform reputation.There are reports and comparative reviews highlighting recalls or safety investigations (e.g., tests in France concerning metal release) which may negatively impact perceived reliability, even if contested by the brand.
Corporate Stability
Financial and organizational stability of the brand or company.
Ideal: Established, stable company with low risk of discontinuing support.
Confidence — MEDIUM
3 sources
65.0% (W 20%)
PRO
Matfer Bourgeat is a family-owned, long‑lived company with origins back to 1814 and ongoing operations worldwide, including a US subsidiary operating for 30+ years, indicating organizational stability.The company has an established global presence and long history of innovation and sustained product supply for professional kitchens.
CON
Independent financial data or recent business performance indicators (e.g., revenue growth, market share) are not readily publicly available, creating uncertainty about current financial strength versus longevity. null
Coverage
Scope of what failures the warranty covers.
Ideal: Full coverage of defects and workmanship, including all major components.
Confidence — HIGH
1 sources
75.0% (W 20%)
PRO
Covers defects in material and workmanship for the life of the product.
CON
Does not cover damage from misuse, improper care, or normal wear.
Duration
Length of warranty term.
Ideal: ≥10 years (lifetime where feasible).
Confidence — HIGH
1 sources
100.0% (W 30%)
DATA
lifetime
Ease
How simple it is to file and process a warranty claim.
Ideal: Clear online or phone process requiring minimal effort or paperwork.
Confidence — MEDIUM
1 sources
65.0% (W 10%)
PRO
Warranty claims can be initiated via email or phone contact with the US office.
CON
No detailed online form or tracking system; process may require direct correspondence and shipping of product.
Cost
Direct costs to the customer for warranty service.
Ideal: No cost to the customer, including free shipping and parts.
Confidence — HIGH
1 sources
100.0% (W 10%)
DATA
no cost for defects
Exclusions
Limitations or carve-outs in warranty terms.
Ideal: Few or no exclusions; coverage applies to all core components.
Confidence — HIGH
1 sources
70.0% (W 10%)
PRO
Covers all core components against defects.
CON
Excludes damage from misuse, improper care, or normal wear and tear.
Transparency
Clarity and accessibility of warranty wording.
Ideal: Plain-language warranty document published openly online.
Confidence — HIGH
1 sources
85.0% (W 10%)
PRO
Warranty terms are published on the brand's US website in plain language.
CON
Transferability
Whether warranty transfers to subsequent owners.
Ideal: Warranty fully transferable between owners with no loss of coverage.
Confidence — LOW
0 sources
0.0% (W 10%)
DATA
Steel Thickness
Thickness of the carbon steel body, which strongly affects resistance to warping and long-term structural integrity.
Ideal: ≥ 3.0 mm thick for full-size skillets to minimize warping under high heat.
Confidence — HIGH
1 sources
50.0% (W 35%)
DATA
2.0 mm
One-Piece Construction
Whether the pan body and handle are formed from a single piece of steel or permanently bonded.
Ideal: Single-piece forged or stamped steel with no welds at stress points.
Confidence — HIGH
1 sources
70.0% (W 25%)
PRO
Pan body is composed of a single pressed piece of steel.
CON
Handle is riveted separately rather than fully one-piece construction.
Heat Warp Resistance
Ability of the skillet to maintain a flat cooking surface when exposed to high or uneven heat.
Ideal: Documented compatibility with high-output burners and minimal reports of spinning or doming.
Confidence — MEDIUM
1 sources
60.0% (W 25%)
PRO
Recommended for use on gas, induction, and glass cooktops with gradual heating to prevent warping.
CON
Rapid heating on induction or glass surfaces may occasionally warp pan in rare cases.
Surface Treatment
Initial surface finish or factory seasoning that can affect corrosion resistance during early use.
Ideal: Bare or lightly pre-seasoned carbon steel with no fragile coatings.
Confidence — HIGH
1 sources
80.0% (W 15%)
PRO
Comes with a high-viscosity vegetable oil-based protective coating to prevent rust during transit.
CON
Requires initial seasoning process to develop non-stick surface; coating must be removed by user.
Handle Attachment Method
Method used to secure the handle, influencing long-term serviceability and strength.
Ideal: Riveted or one-piece handles with standard, accessible fasteners.
Confidence — HIGH
1 sources
85.0% (W 30%)
PRO
Handle is riveted securely to the pan, a standard durable attachment method.
CON
Replacement Handle Availability
Whether replacement handles or compatible parts can be sourced if damaged.
Ideal: Manufacturer-supported or standardized handles available without custom fabrication.
Confidence — LOW
0 sources
20.0% (W 25%)
PRO
CON
No clear information on availability of replacement handles from manufacturer.
Reseasoning Tolerance
Ability of the skillet to be stripped and re-seasoned repeatedly without damage.
Ideal: Safe for abrasive cleaning, oven seasoning, and repeated oil polymerization cycles.
Confidence — HIGH
1 sources
85.0% (W 25%)
PRO
Pan tolerates repeated seasoning cycles and abrasive cleaning without structural damage.
CON
Repair Complexity
Overall difficulty of restoring performance after rust, carbon buildup, or minor deformation.
Ideal: User-serviceable with common tools and household methods.
Confidence — HIGH
1 sources
85.0% (W 20%)
PRO
Rust and carbon buildup can be removed using common household tools; pan can be re-seasoned.
CON
Heat Retention
Capacity of the skillet to store and maintain heat during cooking.
Ideal: High thermal mass suitable for searing and stable temperature cooking.
Confidence — HIGH
2 sources
80.0% (W 30%)
PRO
Carbon steel construction provides good heat retention for searing and stable cooking temperatures.
CON
Heat Responsiveness
How quickly the skillet responds to changes in burner output.
Ideal: Balanced responsiveness that allows control without excessive temperature lag.
Confidence — MEDIUM
1 sources
65.0% (W 20%)
PRO
Responds reasonably well to adjustments on gas and electric stovetops with gradual heat changes.
CON
High-output induction burners may cause uneven heating or delayed surface stabilization initially.
Oven-Safe Temperature
Maximum oven temperature the skillet and handle can safely withstand.
Ideal: ≥ 600 °F (315 °C) with no handle degradation.
Confidence — HIGH
1 sources
90.0% (W 25%)
DATA
600°F (315°C)
Handle Ergonomics
Shape and angle of the handle as it relates to control and fatigue during use.
Ideal: Comfortable grip with balanced weight distribution when fully loaded.
Confidence — MEDIUM
1 sources
70.0% (W 25%)
PRO
Handle is riveted and shaped for a secure grip, providing good control during typical cooking tasks.
CON
Weight distribution may feel slightly front-heavy when pan is fully loaded due to carbon steel body.

See details on our Scoring Method.

Sources

These references are living documents: our research team and community continually review and update them to keep product evaluations accurate and fair. When stronger or more up-to-date sources emerge, we re-score accordingly. If you know of a credible study, review, or technical resource we’ve missed, please share it below — every contribution helps strengthen the evidence base.

  1. The Black Carbon Steel Guide
    matferbourgeatusa.com · Updated 2025-12-18
    Seasoning and care instructions to get the most out of your new favorite pan.
  2. Matfer Bourgeat 062006 12 5/8" Black Carbon Steel Fry Pan
    webstaurantstore.com · Updated 2025-12-18
    A close-up of a Matfer Bourgeat black carbon steel frying pan with a handle.
  3. Matfer Bourgeat Carbon Steel Skillet Review
    thekitchn.com · Updated 2025-12-18
    Nov 25, 2020 ... If you ask the folks at Cook's Illustrated it's the French-made Matfer Bourgeat. The editors there tested carbon steel skillets in 2015 and ...
  4. BENTLY NEVADA 330130-040-02-05 3300XL 8mm STANDARD ...
    localfood.ces.ncsu.edu · Updated 2025-12-18
    While descriptions are believed to be accurate, the sellers make no warranties or guarantees ... Matfer Bourgeat Exoglass Oblong Cake Mould 45mm. 8.99. 28.99.
  5. Matfer Bourgeat Excalibur Fry Pan Products
    matferbourgeatusa.com · Updated 2025-12-18
    Matfer Bourgeat Excalibur Fry Pan. QUALITY MATERIALS: Made of thick stainless steel with a steel-aluminum-steel sandwich bottom.
  6. The Black Carbon Steel Guide
    matferbourgeatusa.com · Updated 2025-12-18
    Seasoning and care instructions to get the most out of your new favorite pan. ... Some companies use this process on fry pans, but Matfer Bourgeat does not.
  7. Recs for induction-compatible cookware and where to buy
    houzz.com · Updated 2025-12-18
    Jan 10, 2025 ... ... Matfer Bourgeat Black Carbon Steel Frying Pan Products Matfer ... it should't matter that you used it; for that price you have a warranty ...
  8. Matfer Bourgeat Black Carbon Steel Frying Pan
    everythingkitchens.com · Updated 2025-12-18
    Matfer Bourgeat Black Carbon Steel Frying Pan 9.5". 0.0. No) ReviewsWrite the First Review. Q&A. Ask a Question. Expect an answer in about 48 hours. 90.00.
  9. Matfer Bourgeat 062001 8 1/2" Black Carbon Steel Fry Pan
    webstaurantstore.com · Updated 2025-12-18
    A Matfer Bourgeat carbon steel fry pan with vegetables cooking on a stove. A close-up of a Matfer Bourgeat black carbon steel frying pan.
  10. WARRANTY and MAINTENANCE
    m.media-amazon.com · Updated 2025-12-18
    WARRANTY and MAINTENANCE. Bourgeat Cookware Warranty. From the date of purchase, MATFER BOURGEAT guarantees to repair or replace any item found defective in.
  11. Matfer Bourgeat Black Carbon Steel Crêpe Pan Products
    matferbourgeatusa.com · Updated 2025-12-18
    Matfer Bourgeat Black Carbon Steel Crêpe Pan. VARIETY OF USES: Sloped shallow walls are perfect for flipping crepes, pancakes, eggs, searing and sautéing, ...
  12. Amazon.com: Matfer Bourgeat Black Carbon Steel Paella Pan, 14 1/8
    amazon.com · Updated 2025-12-18
    Buy Matfer Bourgeat Black Carbon Steel Paella Pan, 14 1/8": Paella Pans ... Customer Review: Holy Paella! Paul. For this product.
  13. The 4 Best Carbon Steel Pans of 2025, Tested & Reviewed
    seriouseats.com · Updated 2025-12-18
    Mauviel M'Steel, Carbon, nonstick Fry Pan, 3.3 lbs ; Matfer Bourgeat Black Carbon Steel Frying Pan, 3.11 lbs ; OXO Obsidian Pre-Seasoned Carbon Steel, 2.6 lbs.
  14. Do I need to season the handle on the Matfer Bourgeat pan? It looks ...
    reddit.com · Updated 2025-12-18
    Nov 29, 2022 ... Do I need to season the handle on the Matfer Bourgeat pan? It looks and feels like it is made of a slightly different material, ...
  15. At my wit's end with my matfer : r/carbonsteel
    reddit.com · Updated 2025-12-18
    Apr 4, 2022 ... 17 votes, 31 comments. Several months ago I got an 11 inch Matfer Bourgeat. It was my first carbon steel fry pan and I was very excited to ...
  16. Matfer Bourgeat Black Carbon Steel Frying Pan, 8 1/2 ... - Amazon.com
    amazon.com · Updated 2025-12-18
    Buy Matfer Bourgeat Black Carbon Steel Frying Pan, 8 1/2": Woks & Stir-Fry Pans - Amazon.com FREE DELIVERY possible on eligible purchases.
  17. French Recall of Matfer Bourgeat Black Carbon Steel Fry Pans: Your ...
    reddit.com · Updated 2025-12-18
    May 8, 2024 ... ... using your Matfer Bourgeat Black Carbon Steel Frying Pan, following the use and care instructions that state that you should properly season ...
  18. Matfer Bourgeat Black Carbon Steel Frying Pan Products
    matferbourgeatusa.com · Updated 2025-12-18
    Matfer Bourgeat Black Carbon Steel Frying Pan. VARIETY OF USES: Top-notch heat retention and temperature control is excellent for searing meats, ...
  19. Black Carbon Steel – Matfer Bourgeat USA
    matferbourgeatusa.com · Updated 2025-12-18
    Black Carbon Steel · Matfer Bourgeat Black Carbon Steel Crêpe Pan · Matfer Bourgeat Black Carbon Steel Paella Pan · Matfer Bourgeat Black Carbon Steel Frying Pan ...
  20. Matfer Bourgeat Black Carbon Steel Frying Pan, 12 5/8" - Walmart.com
    walmart.com · Updated 2025-12-18
    4.5 stars out of 38 reviews. (4.5) . 38. Matfer Bourgeat Black Carbon Steel Frying Pan, 12 5/8". Image 1 of Matfer Bourgeat Black Carbon Steel Frying Pan, 12 5/ ...
  21. Matfer Bourgeat Black Carbon Steel Paella Pan Products
    matferbourgeatusa.com · Updated 2025-12-18
    Matfer Bourgeat Black Carbon Steel Paella Pan ... One of the best-kept secrets in culinary, black steel pans are loved by professionals everywhere for their ...
  22. Our Guarantee
    matferbourgeatusa.com · Updated 2025-12-18
    Claims must be submitted with the defective product and copy of the authorized Matfer Bourgeat USA dealer invoice. Return freight is the responsibility of the ...

Status

Created 2025-12-18 COMPLETE
Updated 2025-12-18 COMPLETE
Published PUBLISHED
Scored 2025-12-18 COMPLETE

Change Log

2025-12-18 UPDATED product metadata edits
2025-12-18 UPDATED product metadata edits
2025-12-18 UPDATED product metadata edits

Improve this Product

Know a trustworthy source we’re missing? See anything off in the scoring or data?